--- Log opened Thu Nov 17 00:00:20 2022
03:59 -!- tibo [~tibo@240d:1a:afa:4000:c9fb:3fd8:8bb2:a924] has quit []
04:01 < yancy> andytoshi I'd like to add coin-selection algos to rust-bitcoin such as select-coins-BnB.  What do you think?  Anything I should be aware before trying to add a repo?
04:06 -!- afilini [~afilini@2001:bc8:1828:245::2] has joined #bitcoin-rust
04:06 < afilini> If you need inspiration we have been working on a new "standalone" coin selection for bdk bere: https://github.com/LLFourn/bdk_core_staging/tree/master/bdk_core/src/coin_select
04:22 < yancy> afilini thanks, I have seen that BDK also has a version of coin-selection
05:58 < andytoshi> yancy: are you suggesting to add a standalone repo with coin selection algos?
05:58 < andytoshi> yeah, i think that's a cool idea
05:59 < andytoshi> i imagine it'd be experimental/hacky for a while .. but once it matures i think it'd be a good candidate for the rust-bitcoin org, if that's what you're asking
05:59 < andytoshi> but initially not, we usually let things start in personal repos then move them over after some discussion period
09:16 < yancy> andytoshi there is a very early implementation I started back in 2019 when I worked with CG - https://github.com/p2pderivatives/rust-bitcoin-coin-selection
09:16 < yancy> I spoke to the owner, tibo and he said he is still using this repo but that it can be moved to rust-bitcoin.
09:16 < yancy> If it's a community project, there are a lot of improvements i'd like to make (I'm currently working as an independent developer).
09:16 < yancy> My thinking is that we can either iterate on this version if it's going to be a community project, or I can start a new version from scratch in my personal repo, or some combination of the two.  Any preference?
09:16 < andytoshi> without looking at it more closely i don't have a preference
09:17 < andytoshi> but i think this should maybe be a discussion on the rust-bitcoin repo
09:17 < andytoshi> so others can chime in and there's some record of what people think
09:17 < andytoshi> but my guess would be that there's some (fairly minor) things that would need to change to pull it into the rust-bitcoin org, and that if it's actively developed, that's the direction we should go in
15:21 -!- tibo [~tibo@fp5a950abc.tkyc110.ap.nuro.jp] has joined #bitcoin-rust
18:56 < ariard> well i didn't see a PR to drop the arg, so just opened a new one
--- Log closed Fri Nov 18 00:00:20 2022